2024 Music: Top 25 Albums of the Year
So final post to wrap up my music listening for 2024. As usual I've made the cut off at my top 25 albums, possibly because this is the longest number of writeups I can manage both without having an aneurysm myself but also without making the list a bit too long for public consumption. So anyway, a lot of these I will have mentioned in my songs writeups or at least they've come up on the top 100 songs list, too, so if there's repetition about why I like some of these, I apologise.
25) I Am I Am - Ruth Theodore (Indie Folk)
This album was a bit of a surprise for me when I relistened for end-of-year consideration. Although it won my album of the week when it came out, I had kind of earmarked it as a potential throwaway in favour of other things. The main reason being this is unassuming, unpretentious, and feels therefore kind of 'standard' folk. But there's a broad storytelling quality to the way Theodore casually delivers her lyrics, as well as some unexpected slow-burn build-ups in the orchestration that make this really quite a profound statement of music despite seeming so simplistically charming on the surface.
24) X's - Cigarettes After Sex (Dreampop)
I've mentioned these guys as they did make my top 50 songs with the title track here, plus a second song lower down in my top 100. But what I felt distinguished this album from its predecessors (and I've heard every Cigarettes After Sex album since they debuted during the time we've been doing this music project and I loved their debut) is this album feels quite powerfully intimate. It's more overtly bedroom pop despite having that ambient, dreamy atmosphere throughout but also the lyrics here feel very intimate and personal. So it may sound weird to say this but it's a very sexy album and it feels like the soundtrack of a couple of horny teenagers embarking on their first consummation - with plenty of drugs and possibly rock 'n' roll involved as well. But also somehow, musically interesting as well.
23) Transfigured Earth - Brendan Byrnes (xenharmonic psychedelic rock)
This is actually a pair of EPs from Brendan Byrnes, who has previously been featured in my top 20 songs (#11 of 2017) and top 25 albums (specifically #25, also in 2017). There's no doubt that on the surface the second EP feels more typically him - it's more electronic, more xenharmonic, and basically more 'alien' while part I is more acoustic and guitar-driven. But I feel it works best as a two-parter, especially taking in mind what he's titled the whole thing and it feels like a transition from a naturalistic, more down-to-earth almost folk rock composition into a more alien soundscape by part II. So Part II could have made a play for this list on its own but I think it definitely earns the build-up developed in Part I as well.
22) Instant Rewards - Tides from Nebula (Polisho Post-Metal)
Another alumnus from a previous list, these guys did my #6 album and #5 song of 2019 and this was therefore their eagerly-await followup five years in the making. Being further down the list it does feel like a bit of a letdown but mainly because I felt they had gone from the experimental and fully hard-hitting instrumental work of their previous album to a more predictable prog-metal style, especially later in this album. There are still some amazingly complex layerings of guitar works but it does feel like more of a melody-driven piece rather than brutalist compounding of sounds which I loved later on - so still great stuff but not top tier this time around.
21) A circle’s round - Lunar Noon (Chamber Psych)
This is the second album I've heard from Lunar Noon but this one really grew on me late in the year (it was a fairly late release, I think mid-November, and in fact the week after Tides from Nebula's album was released). It feels like very 'adult' music in that despite the interplay between chamber instrumentation and psychedelic dreampoppy vibes, it seems to take itself very seriously. And that could fall apart if it wasn't consistently committed to and delivered, but singer-songwriter Michelle Zheng does just that, delivering a kind of jazz-infused chamber pop that's sophisticated and elaborate and it feels worth listening to every moment even if it has a contrived structural quality without a strong sense of fun or whimsy.
20) BUTU - KOKOKO! (Democratic Republic of the Congoleso Underground Electronica)
This one feels like a bit of a sore thumb in the midst of all this sophisticated, professionally-produced music, but the very raw, unrefined quality of this is exactly what makes it so compelling. This is a group of DJs and producers who formed some kind of collective on the streets of Kinshasa, and make this music which feels constantly furious as well as developing a sense of community through these energising dance tunes. It also follows wonderfully in the tradition of Afrobeat with these repeated vocal refrains and exhortations so it's both a thrilling statement of defiance and a celebration of the unifying power of music.
19) A Hellish Lazarus - Agora (experimental rap)
This one was a real surprise for me. Now as a very important sidenote I should mention that this was my album of the week the week that the new album by Hungarian avant-garde metal band Thy Catafalque was released, who in previous years have weirdly harbinged specifically my number 4 album of the year (a prophecy which was broken last year when in fact they harbinged my number 1 album of the year instead). So a bit down this year, but still cracking my top twenty with this one. This is very much a weird album, consisting of a very fuzzy and even aggressive punk-style production with similarly distorted vocals delivering a sense of despair and anguish at an impressively fast-paced tempo. It worked on me because it felt like it earned the build-ups to some pretty hefty and weighty climaxes and felt like a unique personal statement of rap music.
18) 51122 - The FMs (Queer Post-Punk)
This is one of the highest-ranked albums that only won runner-up album in its week of release (there's a very clear reason in this case, with vague references to what will be revealed as my number 1 album of the whole year lower down in this post etc), and I was pleased at how well it held up on relistening. This is a group of trans musicians who I felt only touch upon queer themes in a few tracks here (e.g. "My Sex" and "Domino") but otherwise deliver a variety of pop and rock tunes here. They do this I feel through emphasising different members of the band and their talents at various times so you get a sense of eclecticism while always feeling like it's true to their band identity and sound. Ultimately just a really entertaining album of music.
17) Kantos - Kishi Bashi (Art Pop)
Kishi Bashi is a powerhouse of the music project (My #89, #79 and #4 songs and #3 album of 2016; #33 song and #7 album of 2019; #4 song of 2020 - also my #89 song of this year) so naturally every release of his comes with a huge sense of anticipation. This one was really quite a stylistic departure from him, taking ostensibly on a baroque exploration of nu-disco music rather than his old interrogations of pop music interspersed with his virtuosity on the violin. That made for a bit of a challenge at times when it felt a bit more upbeat and less thoughtful than I'm used to, with him. But there's still so much to enjoy here in terms of his clever arrangements, skillful playing and just sheer smooth, delightful tones throughout. It feels like his most superficial collection of music but I think it's just his most purely playful.
16) Your Hand Forever Checking On My Fever - Amanda Bergman (Swedisho Folk Pop)
Amanda Bergman is the singer for a band called Amason, who did my #14 album of 2019 and who I discovered and loved the year before we started this music project in earnest (specifically 2015, or maybe late 2014). My love for Amanda Bergman's voice and style feels purely idiosyncratic though, because I find something so relaxing about her singing that carries through to the production behind her. It's kind of flawed in a good way, accented in a quirky way, and the gentleness of it feels reassuring that it's OK to be imperfect. Maybe I get overly sentimental about this kind of music because it's far from a monumental artistic statement, but I just think there's a real charm to its quaintness and simplicity.
15) Songdreaming - Sam Lee (Modern Trad Folk)
This album feels like something I'd normally dismiss but there's something utterly compelling, ultimately, about Sam Lee's voice. It's so rich and full of depth and he delivers every part of this with such passion and aplomb. There are some awesome instrumental arrangements as well (most notably in "Aye Walking Oh", my #21 song of the year) that help to elevate this above what it feels like on the surface, which is a pretty typical album of traditional folk songs. If it is ultimately a set of traditional-sounding folk, it's just an especially beautifully delivered set.
14) Born Horses - Mercury Rev (Psychedelic Pop)
There are often albums like this in my top of the year, where bands who have been around for a long time doing the same kind of thing come on my radar for the first time, and I really like them. Mercury Rev feel like one of those groups because I can imagine this kind of theatrical, flamboyant and ultimately kind of pretentious art pop will become a bit tired once you've heard a lot of it. But this was my first taste of it and despite how heightened, stylised and 'weird' the whole thing is, I really went for it in a big way. I think it's largely because the synthpop arrangements are so elaborate and affecting so Jonathan Donahue's vocals setting the scene and telling the story over the top just provide the crowning touch.
13) The Phantom Five - AWOLNATION (Indie Pop Rock)
I feel like AWOLNATION are part of that group of alt/pop rock groups in the 2000s who did a big hit or two and have then continued to put out similar music to diminishing returns of popularity. But I've always really enjoyed these guys in particular, and this album was a surprise hit for me. It's more a collection of bangers than it is a profound singular statement as an album, but through sheer force of great songs (including my #8 and #88 songs of this year) it ended up being a no-brainer for this list. It's just forcefully catchy music based around some great motifs and bringing with it really enjoyable energy.
12) Orchid Underneath - Jane Paknia (Experimental Electropop)
This was another album that I liked on first listen but really accelerated up the list at the end of the year. If I am looking - nine years and counting into this ~1000 albums per year project - for things that surprise me and offer something new and distinctive, this album has it in spades. It's got a wonderful experimentation throughout full of complex juxtapositions that are always wildly unpredictable. But Paknia proves throughout that she can manage subtle just as well as she can do showy which means that the louder and more challenging parts of this are really emphasised and highlighted well to drive the sense of 'weird' when it's needed.
11) Sometimes, Late At Night - Jharis Yokley (Experimental Percussive Synthrock)
Two albums in a row of fairly challenging music. This is my highest-ranked album that only won runner-up of its week and in fact it's leapfrogged the album that beat it, Ruth Theodore's "I Am I Am" which I discussed earlier. I mentioned as well in my songs writeup that this dude feels like he's running where Brian Eno earlier walked in the 70s. He's got the same kind of ambient experimental rock with his rich, evocative vocal line, but in Yokley's case he focuses as well on his byzantine drumbeats underneath to deliver something that's weirdly contrasting between ambient and furiously driving.
10) Fine Art - Kneecap (Northern Irisho Hip-Hop)
This is another album I've touched on in my songs writeups as these guys also made my #15 song of the year. This whole album is a delightful exercise in chaos (Kneecap were also featured in a pseudo-documentary film this year that Jez has seen and said it's also delightfully chaotic) but it's delivered in a strangely and compellingly nonchalant way. There's a potent anger throughout their lyricism and the production and arrangements behind them but a lot of the casual delivery just adds to how unapologetically Irish (northern or otherwise) this is - there's a sense of skylarking throughout where they're pissed off at everything but still determined to have fun in spite of it all.
9) Dulling the Horns - Wild Pink (Indie Folk Rock)
Another powerhouse of the music project, this is the first Wild Pink (full-length) album that hasn't been in my top 3 albums of the year so it feels like a big demotion despite still making my top ten (just to be boring and document everything, their previous credits are: #38, #32, #28 songs and #3 album of 2018; #81, #51, #9 and #5 songs and #1 album of 2021; #96 and #67 songs and #2 album of 2022). This album was a bit of a departure for them though, which seems to have been noted as a positive in this case for many critics but for me I really liked the sentimental, dreamy and comforting feel of their previous albums. Their 2022 effort ILYSM did develop a bit more of the rock edge that's predominant here. But there's still a wonderful sense of the surreal in their songwriting here, and John Ross' voice still delivers these potent feelings while maintaining in this case a bigger, cooler presence and sense of drive.
8) BETA - Peter Cat Recording Co. (Indiano Art Rock)
This is probably the most idiosyncratic pick I have on my list, and I say that largely because - God help me - I have no idea why I love this album so much. Peter Cat Recording Co are an Indian band, and the whole premise of this album - and possibly their sound generally, this is my only taste of them so far - is this esoteric take on classic lounge jazz crooning. Think something like Perry Como or Dean Martin or Engelbert Humperdinck. But it does that interspersed with subtle but ever-present Indian folk instrumentation as well as a more modernist sense of lyricism which imbues it all with a touch of cynicism and almost undermines the overtly sentimental tone of the music. There's undoubtedly a tacky feel to this but that's part of what I find so fascinating in this, and at the end of the day I enjoy a lot of the tunes they crank out here in spite of whatever else might feel off-putting here.
Yet another frequent appearer on these lists (among others they did my #12 album of 2018 and #19 album of 2021), James have reached their highest point yet with this, the worst-named album on this list (I've said that, if James have a particular strength, it definitely isn't choosing album titles or band names). Similar but superior to AWOLNATION, this is just an album of wall-to-wall bangers. It feels at times as catchy as the Fratellis, it feels at other times as sweeping and grandiose as U2, it feels at other times sophisticated and innovative like Elbow or Alt-J. But they are also unmistakeably themselves, and the charisma of frontman Tim Booth is central to every part of this and every part that's good. There's synth elements, there's string elements, and all of it is purposeful and thoughtful as much as it's just infectious and even exhilarating.
6) Revelator - Phosphorescent (Art Folk)
Well you can stop being sick of hearing the name Phosphorescent (whom, like I said in my previous post, I'll be watching perform live tonight at the Factory theatre) because this is the last mention. Having made my top 100 songs of this year 4 times culminating in my runner-up song of the year, this was inevitably going to be a top ten album of the year - as was his 2018 effort as well. The unfortunate and sad thing is that this should be a #1 album of the year (as should his 2018 effort, too) but I feel Phosphorescent's curse is that because he makes such unadorned and simply constructed songs, there's nowhere to hide when the song isn't firing those feels at me. And the truth here, as it was in 2018, is that there are just some weaker songs on here that end up dragging it notably down the rankings where it otherwise should belong. And that's not to say I want him to just cut it all down to four-track EPs or something, but it's just part and parcel of being such a humanistic songwriter that not all of it's going to fire, and as such being my sixth-favourite album of the year is nonetheless a huge achievement and testament to how powerful the best of his songs are.
5) Only Love Remains - Yemen Blues (Yemenio Folk-Grunge)
As a bit of background, I do often tend to love music that has a sense of east-meets-west fusion and/or traditional folk sounds with modern styles, and this album from Yemeni band Yemen Blues is a truly exciting, electrifying album. It’s cultural fusion certainly with a vibrant, modern edge but that just feels like the starting point: beyond that it expands excitingly into an exploration of genre depths and strictures, playing with the grunt and oomph of rock, the wailing of blues and the stirring of folk. But all of that in a package that’s extremely entertaining and lively; great drive, great complexity throughout. It's kind of eclectic in its explorations but remains very solidly Yemeni in spirit and energy, and just gathers more steam as it has these side quests and variations as it goes on.
4) Pages - Shaznay Lewis (Pop RnB)
Shaznay Lewis came up in my earlier post from today, as she made my #5 song of the year which was effectively just a highlight track from this album. But as important context it's worth noting that All Saints are one of those 90s groups that I have a weird fondness for despite them not really being my thing at the time. So Shaznay Lewis as one of their former members and songwriters branching out in solo form was a real revelation for me here. The fact is she's a hell of a songwriter, and while there are a couple of lulls between bangers on this album, everything she's made here is extremely solid and results in very trim, perfecting pop music. It's not overtly RnB in style this, but at the same time it uses her strong voice to its fullest potential a lot of these great arrangements so she's the driving force behind some incredibly efficient and catchy pop tunes. "Peaches" is a big highlight track for me here but there isn't a bad song on here at all.
3) Warriors - Lin-Manuel Miranda and Eisa Davis (Non-Musical Theatre Concept Hip-Hop)
This is potentially a controversial choice given that I feel Lin Manuel-Miranda's star has started to fall in a lot of people's opinions, and also I know this project felt to a lot of people like a weird choice for him now. But the fact is I love the film The Warriors that this is a musical reworking of, and it felt like such a great fit for LMM's style of conceptual storytelling hip-hop. In fact this album made me question why on earth nobody has yet made a musical version of The Warriors because, as this album aptly demonstrates, the camp excesses of the material is ripe for this kind of melodrama and vibrant hip-hop and song-narrating action. There's so much of this album that is exciting to me even though this isn't actually a stage production and is just the soundtrack for a hypothetical staging (that I really want to happen now), and there's so much action in this that happens from the lyrics and music alone. There's also a wonderful ensemble cast of vocal talent on here, from the featured rappers in "Survive the Night" (my #20 song of the year) to Lauryn Hill, Shenseea and, perhaps most notably, Australia's own Kim Dracula who puts in an amazing performance as the villain Luther. A potentially controversial choice maybe but a very firm lock at the top my year for myself.
2) Songs of a Lost World - The Cure (Gothic Rock)
This is not a controversial choice at all and is one area where I seem to agree with the critics who invariably proclaimed this as one of their top albums of the year (although I disagree with them strongly that Charli XCX's Brat should even be in the same conversation as this, let alone universally agreed to be the best album of the year). But worth noting as well that this isn't a case where I'm late to the band's party; I've heard a lot of the Cure's albums from the 80s although I didn't really grow up with them, but nevertheless this felt like a really powerful and frankly quite moving addition to their storied catalogue that also rises above so much of what came before it. I don't mean to be a prognosticator of doom but this really feels like the Cure's version of David Bowie's Blackstar or Leonard Cohen's You Want It Darker in being a final release before shuffling off the mortal coil. There's a palpable sense of mortality ingrained in this album, and Robert Smith's vocals still hold a lot of excellent tone and feeling but they certainly feel like there's a world-weary but also sentimental feeling creeping into them here as it feels so reflective and all-encompassing of the music they've always made together. But as I mentioned when talking about Endsong, my #19 song of the year, the other thing that's on full display here is how skillful and confident the guitar and drum work and bandwork generally are here. They are constantly on song here and the vibrancy of their playing means this is constantly weighty and heavy-seeming in keeping with the tone of gloom and finality but also dynamic and never getting bogged down in a sense of self-importance. This earns every minute it runs for and makes it come to life.
1) The Last Will & Testament - Opeth (Prog Death Metal)